Saturday, March 31, 2012

Political Science and Physics Envy

After an appropriately long hiatus, I return. 

Kevin Clarke and David Primo have a really nice piece in the NY Times this weekend. They boil down the essence of their recent book in arguing that: 

1. Political scientists have a fetish for going about science as physicists do. 
2. Physicists don't really do science this way. 

The alternative they propose is to think of models -- both empirical and theoretical -- as maps. The consequence of this is that they are judged by how practical they are, given their stated purpose. It's a compelling argument. I've used various drafts of Clarke and Primo's book in teaching fourth year specialist students about the nature of political science. I've also recommended it widely to grad students in our program at Toronto. Most importantly, it's done a lot to shape my thinking around how to go about empirical political science. It's worth picking up. 

6 comments:

Marta Clavero said...

scholastic ability test in mathematics, announced the result of the survey asking 220 students to vote for the celebrities who seem to be good/bad at math.

For the category asking student to vote for celebrities VoucherCodesNet
personalized bath robes

Geschäftsgelegenheit global
replica breitling navitimer

smafolk sale
best multivitamins

send text message online
Cloud Hosted Desktop

ราคาบอล
solar cell how to make

Latest Discount Codes
Fontaine eau

manga
teacher courses

Accident Insurance
Miami Interior Designer

text free
how to last longer in bed for men

alarm systems for home
strapless bras
who seem to be good at math, actress Kim Tae Hee ranked first with 43.4% of the votes, and Lee Seung Gi followed with 30.9% of the votes. According to the students, “Lee Seung Gi looks smart and intelligent” and “Kim Tae Hee went to Seoul National University, she is smart for real.”

On the other hand, for celebrities who seem to be bad at math, Boom ranked first with 45.15% of votes,

Dan said...

I have, in the most scientific way possible, created a U.S. presidential election game. Would love it if you checked it out: www.americanhistoryusa.com/campaign-trail/

Anonymous said...

Mr Loewen....long time no see! Busy boy, you've come far from your roots in NB. Congrats on all your accomplishments Pete,
Sara T ;)

gutscheine zum ausdrucken said...

very good comment

sewa mobil jakarta said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.

runescape gold said...

We've, from the many clinical way you can, developed a Oughout.S. presidential selection video game. Would want the idea if you looked at against each other:

rs gold for sale
FFXIV CD Key